ORDER ONLINE

We offer a variety of flavors to choose from. Please choose your selections from the lists below or feel free to inquire with a request. *Please note - Cakes come standard Vanilla if an alternative is not selected. *Can be made GF by request

Each box comes with 4 4" 2 layer cake samples. 2 flavors for the bride, 2 flavors for the groom. White Wedding *Vanilla cake filled with vanilla buttercream* Vintage Wedding *Almond cake filled with vanilla buttercream* Chocolate *Chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream* Churro Cake *Churro cake filled with cinnamon vanilla buttercream* *Can be made GF by request

If you would like to add accessories, cake toppers, flowers, etc. to your cake, please message me with your ideas so that I can give you more accurate pricing.

This gorgeous one of a kind cake is truly a unique gift! If you want to impress someone, WOW them with THIS cake! The cake comes with a 6" bottom tier and 4" top tier (the back half of the cake will be boxed seperately for you), your choice of filling, color pattern, and limited decor as well as an easel. Let me create this little beauty for you!!! *Can be made GF by request

Our cheesecake is rich, smooth, and luxuriously creamy, baked to perfection with a velvety texture that melts in every bite. Set on a buttery, graham cracker crust, in regular or gluten free!

Looking for a fun activity for any age? This sweet experience is perfect for: 💗 Birthday parties 💗 Girls’ night out 💗 Family fun 💗 Date nights 💗 Kids Each kit includes: 💖 One 4" cake 💖 3 icing colors (white is pre-selected) 💖sprinkles to match Create it. Love it. Eat it. 😋 *Minimum purchase of 2 *Can be made GF by request

A handcrafted King Cake made with tender, lightly sweet dough, filled and topped with icing and traditional Mardi Gras colors. Regular or Gluten-Free

Teacup Cake fluffy vanilla cake baked inside a beautiful floral teacup, topped with creamy buttercream, sprinkles, and a happy birthday, happy anniversary or Love sign. The perfect little treat! *Teacup styles, vary* Available in vanilla, chocolate, & gluten- free!

A handcrafted 5" cake paired with six fresh roses, styled together on a square cake board for a stunning and indulgent presentation. Elegant, and gift-ready! Comes with a customizable saying written on the board (“I Love You" “Happy Anniversary,” names, etc.). Beautifully packaged in a clear box & bow Flavors ~ a delicious combination of chocolate, strawberry, & vanilla *Can be made GF by request

This cute little box makes the perfect gift! The bento comes with a 4" cake (serves up to 6) and 5 cupcakes. Treat yourself or someone you love with something adorable! *Can be made GF by request

Tara's Panetteria offers delivery of your tiered cake or minimum orders for a fee within a 10 mile radius. *Free Delivery for all (non-tiered cake) orders over $350 within a 10 mile radius. *Customer pick-ups are available, but are not recommended for multi-tiered cakes or large orders. If you choose to pick up your multi-tired cake, or large order, I cannot ensure it's safe delivery and you assume responsibility.

A timeless Italian-American classic made for celebrations. Layers of light, delicate sponge cake are brushed with aromatic rum syrup, then filled with rich vanilla pastry cream and decadent chocolate pastry cream. Finished with silky whipped cream and an elegant touch of chocolate, every bite is beautifully moist, creamy, and full of old-world flavor. A traditional favorite that brings the taste of an Italian pasticceria to your table.

A classic 8" Italian apple cake generously filled with fresh apples and warm notes of vanilla and cinnamon. Soft, buttery and incredibly moist, with tender apples in every bite. Finished simply with a dusting of powdered sugar, just as it should be. A rustic Italian favorite that's perfect for dessert—or alongside a cup of coffee.

A bright and elegant Italian lemon cake inspired by the flavors of Capri. Made with finely ground almonds, fresh lemon zest, and white chocolate, this naturally gluten-free cake is beautifully moist and tender with a delicate, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Finished with a light dusting of powdered sugar for a simple, classic Italian touch. Rich yet refreshing, with vibrant citrus flavor and the perfect balance of sweetness and almond.

A rich, 10" tender Bundt cake made with butter, olive oil, fresh orange zest, and orange liqueur, almond liqueur, and vodka. Each slice offers bright citrus flavor with a delicate almond finish. *contains alcohol

Layers of flaky puff pastry filled with rich, smooth pastry cream, creating a delicate balance of crispiness and creamy indulgence. This classic Italian dessert is elegant, flavorful, and perfect for sharing at your holiday gatherings.

A traditional Italian desert for any celebration featuring layers of crispy puff pastry, a rich velvety vanilla custard, raspberry drizzle, topped with fresh raspberries and dusted with powdered sugar. **PLEASE call for Custom orders and Custom sizing**

Delicate vanilla sponge cake rolled with silky pistachio cream, coated in roasted pistachios, topped with a swirl of pistachio buttercream, rich chocolate ganache, and finished with a roasted pistachio. Available in your choice of two decadent fillings: 🌿 Pistachio Cream Filled with our smooth, rich pistachio cream for the ultimate pistachio lover. 🍫 Pistachio Gianduja Filled with our signature pistachio cream and Tara's Panetteria's homemade chocolate hazelnut spread for a rich, Italian-inspired combination of pistachio and chocolate.

Traditional Italian sweet pastry filled with silky Italian pastry cream and Amarena cherries, baked until golden and finished with powdered sugar.

A traditional Italian pastry with a delicate, buttery pasta frolla shell surrounding a rich, flavorful center. Bocconotti originated in Southern Italy, with treasured variations found throughout Abruzzo, Puglia and Calabria. Their name comes from boccone, meaning “a bite” in Italian—a nod to these irresistible little pastries traditionally made to be enjoyed in just a few bites. Handmade in small batches at Tara’s Panetteria and finished with a light dusting of powdered sugar. Perfect alongside espresso or coffee, on a dessert table, or tucked into an Italian pastry box.

A decadent tiramisu made with layers of espresso-soaked lady fingers, silky mascarpone cream, and a rich dusting of cocoa powder. Light yet indulgent, this Italian-inspired treat delivers the perfect balance of coffee, cream, and sweetness in every bite. *Can be made GF by request

These Sicilian pastries consist of fried pastry dough, filled with a sweet, creamy filling.

We have a variety of flavors to choose from. Please select your options below. Cupcakes are sold by the dozen. Option to select one flavor per dozen purchased. *Can be made GF by request

Indulge that someone special with our yummy cake pops! Each box is thoughtfully crafted with a dozen pops to bring joy and make your celebrations extra special with each bite sized treat! *Can be made GF by request

Indulge yourself with these delightful cakesicles! Each box of a dozen cakesicles is thoughtfully crafted to bring joy and yummy goodness to your day! *Can be made GF by request

Our chocolate dipped pretzel rods are the perfect blend of sweet and salty indulgence. Crisp, crunchy pretzel rods are hand-dipped in premium chocolate and finished with elegant drizzles, festive toppings, or seasonal decorations. Beautifully crafted and irresistibly delicious, they make the perfect treat for gifting, dessert tables, party favors, or simply enjoying anytime.

Cake Cones are a fun twist on traditional cake! Each handcrafted cone is filled with layers of moist cake, luscious filling, and silky buttercream, then beautifully decorated to match your celebration. Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, weddings, graduations, corporate events, or simply treating yourself, these individually portioned desserts offer all the flavor of a custom cake in a unique, handheld presentation. Available in chocolate, vanilla, funfetti, and strawberry Choice of fillings Custom colors and themes available Individually packaged upon request

Handcrafted Rice Krispies treats dipped in decadent chocolate and beautifully decorated to match your event theme. The perfect sweet touch for birthdays, showers, holidays, and every celebration in between. *Naturally Gluten-Free!!

Chocolate Covered Oreos are the perfect bite sized treat! Choose the amount of cookies you would like, and I will decorated in the style or theme of your choice! *Can be made GF by request

Share a taste of Italian tradition with our beautifully arranged Italian Cookie Platters — the perfect way to show how much you care! Each platter features your choice of One, Two, or three dozen assorted cookies, handmade in small batches with love and the finest ingredients: 🍪 Apricot Amaretti – soft almond cookies filled with sweet apricots. 🍫 Chocolate Amaretti – rich, chewy, and perfectly balanced with a hint of cocoa. 🌼 Italian Butter Cookies – delicate and buttery, dipped in chocolate and decorated with sprinkles. Anise Cookies - Traditional Italian anise cookies—crisp, soft, and infused with aromatic anise flavor. 🌰 Italian Almond Cookies – crisp on the outside, soft within, and full of classic almond flavor. Beautifully presented on a seasonal platter, these cookies make a stunning addition to any dessert table — or a thoughtful gift to share with your loved ones.

Traditional Italian Pistachio cookies are crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside and are a naturally dairy and gluten-free treat.

These Italian cookies are a holiday favorite! Traditional Italian anise-flavored cookies are topped with a yummy frosting and sprinkles.

These classic Italian butter cookie sandwhiches are a buttery treat with a raspberry center, dipped in chocolate & coated in sprinkles.

Delicious buttery but not overly sweet cookie, covered in walnuts and printed in the center with raspberry preserves.

Delicate, old-world pastry cookies with a tender, flaky bite. Our kiffles are rolled thin, filled with ruit preserves, then baked until lightly golden and finished with a snowfall of powdered sugar. Not too sweet and irresistibly buttery, these Eastern European classics melt in your mouth and pair perfectly with coffee or tea.

Baci Di Dama; Italian Chocolate Hazelnut Cookies are a delicious crunchy cookie filled with chocolatey goodness.

Southern Italy's Pignoli cookies are full of almond flavor with a chewy texture, light golden color, and studded with golden pine nuts.

These almond beauties have a little crunch on the outside and are soft and chewy on the inside. One bite of these classic Sicilian biscuits and you will fall in love!

These classic Italian treats are fluffy almond cake layers, covered in raspberry and apricot jam, and then covered in a smooth layer of chocolate. $24.99 per pound (2lb minimum) *Can be made GF by request

This almond cookie is a "must" of the Sicilian tradition. They are prepared with citrus which give it that intense flavor, along with "King's paste", or as we refer to it in the U.S., "Almond paste". And the cherry on top? These irresistible cookies are naturally gluten-free!

Italian almond paste cookies, also known as almond macaroons, are a soft, chewy, flourless cookie, rolled in almonds and topped with a cherry.

Delicious and classic; these soft Italian cookies are full of almond, apricot, and amaretto flavor and as a bonus, they are naturally dairy free and gluten free!

This recipe combines almond flour with a few simple ingredients for a delicious dairy and gluten free chocolate Italian classic!

Italian Waffle Cookie. These authentic Artisanal Pizzelle Cookies are made to order and made from scratch. Each sleeve includes 12 pizzelle's in the flavor or your choice. *Can be made GF by request

Bring the authentic warmth of Tara’s Panetteria into your home. A perfect curation of our signature 4-ounce artisan cookies, hand-packed in our elegant, boutique gift box. Whether you are indulging in a personal treat or sending a sophisticated culinary gift, each assortment is baked to order and beautifully presented to ensure an unforgettable unboxing experience.

Our 4oz. cookie features a decadent Dutch-processed cocoa dough, folded with premium semi-sweet chocolate chunks and stuffed with whole, decadent balls of rich, creamy peanut butter. Baked to a beautiful golden finish, it offers a delicate outer crust, a dense, fudge-like interior, and luscious peanut butter that flows elegantly with every bite.

The ultimate indulgence for the true chocolate connoisseur. Our signature quarter-pound cookie begins with a rich, velvety black-cocoa dough crafted with premium creamery butter. We fold in an abundance of oversized semi-sweet chocolate chunks that melt into molten pools when warmed. Perfectly crisp on the outer edges with a dense, fudge-like center, this decadent masterpiece delivers a deeply intense, luxurious chocolate experience.

Our signature quarter-pound cookie features a buttery dough deeply infused with fresh-pressed lemon juice and fragrant zest. We fold in handmade, tart raspberry chips that offer a vibrant burst of berry flavor in every bite. Soft, dense, and wonderfully refreshing, this oversized treat delivers a sophisticated harmony of sweet lemon and tart summer raspberries.

A breathtaking masterpiece inspired by the flavors of the Italian coast. Our signature quarter-pound cookie features a rich, buttery dough deeply infused with premium ground Sicilian pistachios for an authentic, earthy flavor. We fold in sweet, vibrant strawberry chips that offer a brilliant pop of summery fruit. Perfectly crisp on the outer edges with a dense, melt-in-your-mouth center, this elegant treat delivers an exquisite harmony of savory nuttiness and sweet berry brightness.

A refined homage to a nostalgic classic. Our signature 4oz. cookie features a rich, golden graham-infused dough folded with velvety chocolate chunks and premium toasted marshmallows. Baked to perfection, it boasts a delicate outer crisp and a decadently soft, center, delivering an upscale fireside experience in every bite.

A refined twist on a classic favorite. Our signature 40z. sugar cookie is elevated with a generous fold of rich, buttery toffee pieces. Baked to a perfect golden finish, it offers a delicate outer crisp, a soft, melt-in-your-mouth center, and a deeply satisfying caramel crunch in every bite.

A luxurious European-inspired indulgence. Our signature quarter-pound cookie base is deeply infused with smooth Biscoff cookie butter, then folded with creamy white chocolate chunks and biscoff cookie pieces. Baked with crispy, golden edges and a beautifully soft, rich center, it offers a sophisticated harmony of caramelized cinnamon and velvety sweetness

A legendary indulgence crafted with an artisan touch. Our signature quarter-pound cookie honors a famous culinary tradition, featuring a delicate base made with finely ground old-fashioned oats and real creamery butter. We fold in premium semi-sweet chocolate chunks, finely grated milk chocolate, and crisp toasted walnuts. Perfectly baked to achieve a beautifully golden outer crust and a wonderfully dense, chewy heart, it delivers a complex and luxurious chocolate experience.

Custom Sugar Cookie Cut-outs. So cute and totally delicious! *Can be made GF by request

Each box includes 4 freshly baked, soft vanilla or chocolate sugar cookies, 3 bags of vibrant icing, and fun sprinkles so you can create your own edible masterpieces at home. Ideal for parties, family activities, gifts, or a sweet afternoon project, this kit brings all the fun of cookie decorating—no baking required. Just open the box, decorate, and enjoy every delicious bite.

Paint your own cookies are so much fun for the kids! Let their artristry come to life on their own special cookie! These sugar cookies are a wonderful addition to any party or celebration! *Can be made GF by request

Five hand-decorated sugar cookies styled as a baby’s wardrobe, finished with royal icing and displayed hanging on a clothes rack. Adorable and perfect for baby showers, christenings, gender reveals, and more! Your colors Your design *Can be made GF by request

Our Wedding Dress Wardrobe is a stunning collection of five custom sugar cookies, each hand-designed to resemble an elegant wedding dress. Featuring timeless silhouettes and delicate details, this set is perfect for bridal showers, engagement parties, wedding favors, or gifting the bride-to-be something truly special. Looking to include the whole bridal party? This set can also be made in bridesmaid dress styles to match your wedding palette or theme 💗 *Can be made GF by request